What is the most valuable card in Archenemy Schemes?

As of August 8, 2026, the most valuable Archenemy Schemes card tracked by CardIntel is All in Good Time #1★ with a reference price of $48.16.

How are these prices calculated?

Each price is the CardIntel published reference price: market snapshots layered with verified eBay completed-sale evidence where available, with thin or runaway quotes suppressed. Every card page shows the price with its as-of date, source, and confidence.

How many Archenemy Schemes cards does CardIntel track?

CardIntel tracks 45 Archenemy Schemes cards, 45 of them with a published price.

Magic: The Gathering · Archenemy Schemes

The most valuable cards in Archenemy Schemes.

As of August 8, 2026, the most valuable Archenemy Schemes card is All in Good Time #1★ at $48.16. Rankings use the CardIntel published reference price — market snapshots layered with verified sale evidence, thin quotes suppressed — for 45 priced cards of the 45 tracked in this set.

Top 25 rankedAs of August 8, 2026Full Archenemy Schemes hub →

#	Card	Rarity	Reference Price
1	All in Good Time#1★	common	$48.16
2	Behold the Power of Destruction#4★	common	$18.49
3	Dance, Pathetic Marionette#6★	common	$17.91
4	My Undead Horde Awakens#29★	common	$16.10
5	The Very Soil Shall Shake#41★	common	$15.65
6	Mortal Flesh Is Weak#26★	common	$15.00
7	Evil Comes to Fruition#12★	common	$14.50
8	Surrender Your Thoughts#39★	common	$14.39
9	Tooth, Claw, and Tail#40★	common	$14.35
10	My Crushing Masterstroke#27★	common	$14.08
11	Embrace My Diabolical Vision#9★	common	$13.59
12	My Genius Knows No Bounds#28★	common	$13.10
13	May Civilization Collapse#25★	common	$12.80
14	Know Naught but Fire#23★	common	$12.45
15	I Call on the Ancient Magics#16★	common	$11.62
16	A Display of My Dark Power#8★	common	$9.99
17	Into the Earthen Maw#20★	common	$9.73
18	Nothing Can Stop Me Now#33★	common	$9.48
19	The Fate of the Flammable#13★	common	$8.32
20	The Dead Shall Serve#7★	common	$6.82
21	I Know All, I See All#18★	common	$6.62
22	Every Hope Shall Vanish#10★	common	$5.99
23	I Bask in Your Silent Awe#15★	common	$4.99
24	The Pieces Are Coming Together#35★	common	$4.98
25	Only Blood Ends Your Nightmares#34★	common	$4.87

Prices are dated reference values, not live quotes — cite them together with the as-of date above. Attribution: CardIntel (cardintel.io). See the methodology for how reference prices are built.